rerum expetendarum
fugiendarumque scientia
Knowledge does not, of itself, amount to judgment.
There is seldom any shortage of expertise around a difficult conundrum. The ordeal lies in bringing different facets of Knowledge into some intelligible relation with one another, and in knowing what weight each ought to carry when a decision must finally be made.
Law may define what is permissible. Economics may reveal the incentives and consequences. Technology may determine what can in fact be done. Institutions, organisations and human behaviour introduce further constraints, interests and contingencies.
Complexity begins at the point where expertise ceases to be sufficient on its own.
What deserves to matter.
τέλος Thelos: to uncover the structure beneath the apparent predicament, to bring different shapes of Knowledge into a single intelligible view, and to give that understanding sufficient form and discipline to support action.
Counsel
Independent judgment and strategic perspective in matters where several forms of expertise must be brought together.
Intervention
Direct involvement when judgment must become execution, including periods of transition, special situations and temporary executive responsibility.
Design
The framing of agreements, organisations, transactions, governance and decision processes so that they work in practice as well as in theory.
Resolution
The movement from uncertainty, negotiation or competing interests towards a coherent and workable outcome.
Between knowledge and action stands judgment.
Aristotle distinguished phronesis from knowledge concerned with truth alone: practical wisdom belonged instead to the realm of choice, circumstance and action. Cicero carried the same tradition into prudentia, understood as the capacity to discern what ought to be pursued and what ought to be avoided.
Complexity
Adviser
The Complexity Adviser belongs to no single discipline: it may require counsel, strategy, design or direct executive involvement, according to the nature of the matter at hand. Its subject is not a particular industry, function or professional category, but the problem in its full shape.
What changes is the form of engagement. What remains constant is the method: to apprehend the whole, distinguish what is material, exercise judgment, give that judgment structure, and carry it through to consequence.
What should be pursued?
What should be avoided?
What follows?